How Steve Jobs gaslighted journalist about Apple’s TV ambitions | Cult of Mac

How Steve Jobs gaslighted journalist about Apple’s TV ambitions


Why Salesforce chief gave up for Apple
Did Jobs second guess himself on Apple's TV potential?
Photo: Ben Stanfield/Flickr CC

Apple has been working towards its TV ambitions for more than a decade now, ever since it launched the original Apple TV in 2007. However, a new anecdote from technology journalist Nick Bilton makes clear just how unsure the company has been in the past about its goals with television.

Bilton recalls a meeting with Steve Jobs in 2010. During the encounter, Jobs backtracked on his previous claim that TV was going to be a core business for Apple. Things have certainly changed!

Writing for Vanity Fair, Bilton notes that:

“At the time, I was a cub reporter at The New York Times, but given that I covered Apple, I was invited to attend the event, which included a hands-on demo and a private Q&A session with Steve Jobs. About halfway through the demo, I asked Jobs a somewhat impertinent question—one that was wholly unrelated to the iPad, but which is entirely relevant today.

‘In 2007, you unveiled the Apple TV, and while you were sitting on stage, you described Apple’s core businesses as a three-legged stool,’ I said to Jobs. ‘You said you hoped Apple TV would be the fourth leg of that stool. Yet, three years later, Apple TV sales are paltry. Did you get it wrong?’ Jobs dismissively denied—in front of the top editors at the paper—that he had ever said that.

I began to push back, but Jobs interrupted me. ‘Nick, I did not say that.” He was emphatic. As I opened my mouth again to argue, Jobs stopped me, stared me dead in the eye, and said: ‘For us, Apple TV is just a hobby.'”

Bilton says that Jobs’ gaslighting caused him to question whether he really had seen what he thought he had during Jobs’ Apple TV keynote in 2007. (Spoiler: he had.)

After the meeting, Bilton spoke with veteran reporter John Markoff, and showed him the video of Jobs saying the words he had denied saying just minutes earlier. Markoff laughed and said, “Welcome to the Steve Jobs reality distortion field.”

Apple’s finally ready to try

It’s a fun Steve Jobs anecdote. But it also shows just how far Apple has come since then. Jobs publicly called the Apple TV a hobby for years. Later in 2010, he introduced the second-gen model. When he announced it on stage, the banner behind him read: “One more thing hobby.”

Rumors that Apple was going to launch its own TV set were sparked by Jobs’ biography. As part of it, he told Walter Isaacson that he had finally cracked the problem of the perfect TV interface. But Apple never launched such a TV.

Since then, its television ambitions have gradually broadened under Tim Cook. We’ve had reinventions of the Apple TV, including its current 4K iteration. But it seems that, finally, 12 years after Jobs talked about television being a core business for Apple, it’s actually happening. Whether it can deliver on its promise remains to be seen.

Are you optimistic that Apple can make a success of its television ambitions? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.


Daily round-ups or a weekly refresher, straight from Cult of Mac to your inbox.

  • The Weekender

    The week's best Apple news, reviews and how-tos from Cult of Mac, every Saturday morning. Our readers say: "Thank you guys for always posting cool stuff" -- Vaughn Nevins. "Very informative" -- Kenly Xavier.