Mobile menu toggle

The 17 best Apple Watch tidbits from early reviews

By

Apple Watch Edition
Early reviewers are in love with Apple Watch. Photo: Apple
Photo: Apple

The first wave of Apple Watch reviews landed this morning with the consensus that Apple has created the best smartwatch ever. Now whether you actually need a smartwatch is still being heavily debated, but the early Apple Watch reviews have highlighted some pretty compelling cases.

Reviews from tech news sites have praised Apple Watch for its innovative UI and incredible design. After slogging through the first reviews though, the most interesting insights I found about Apple Watch came from non-tech sites. What will it be like for normal, non-tech nerds to use Apple’s timepiece?

Here’s everything new I learned about Apple Watch from reading all the reviews:

Activating the display can be tricky

apple-watch-display
“The Apple Watch activates its screen only when it thinks you’re looking at it. Sometimes a subtle twist of your wrist will do, but sometimes it takes … more. Many times while using the watch, I had to swing my wrist in an exaggerated upward motion to bring the display to life…. Sometimes, even if you do the arm-swing motion, the screen doesn’t turn on. Sometimes it turns on, then off. Sometimes you tap it and nothing happens.” – Joshua Topolsky, Bloomberg

Your kid will want one

“The first time my almost 7-year-old son spied the watch, he exclaimed, ‘Mom, you got a new phone!’ instantly making the connection between the new device on my wrist and the iPhone I’m typically clutching in my hand. By day three, after we’d sent a few audio texts to his grandma in Florida and he was clued into the 22nd-century possibilities of the thing, he was lobbying for one of his own. The Mickey Mouse face suggests to me that Apple gets the potential the Watch has with generation Z.” – Nicole Phelps, Style

Notifications require lots of tweaking

apple-watch-notification

“Do you want every email to buzz your wrist, or just those from your VIPs? How about social apps like Twitter — when should you let them ring your watch? I spent many hours pondering such questions, and there was a lot of fine-tuning in the notification screen on my phone. In other words, it didn’t just work.” – Farhad Manjoo, The New York Times

The jellyfish and butterfly screens aren’t animated

“We shot all this stuff,” Apple human interface chief Alan Dye told Wired, “the butterflies and the jellyfish and the flowers for the motion face, it’s all in-camera. And so the flowers were shot blooming over time. I think the longest one took us 285 hours, and over 24,000 shots.”

iPad tethering is a no-go

Battery life is solid

“After more than a week of daily use, Apple Watch has more than alleviated any concerns I had about getting through a day on a single charge. I noted the remaining charge when I went to bed each night. It was usually still in the 30s or 40s. Once it was still over 50 percent charged. Once, it was down to 27. And one day — last Thursday — it was all the way down to 5 percent. But that day was an exception — I used the watch for an extraordinary amount of testing, nothing at all resembling typical usage.” – John Gruber, DaringFireball

Third party apps suck (for now)

h692

“I often found that new apps took forever to install, and they then worked sporadically. I installed Trivia Crack and initially couldn’t get it to work. It took initiating a game on the iPhone for it to finally be available on the watch.” – Lance Ulanoff, Mashable

It’ll help you find your iPhone

Ben Bajarin at TechPinions noted that one of his favorite simple features is using Apple Watch to find a lost iPhone. “The ability to use the watch to ping your iPhone so you can find it if you have misplaced it. A quick “find my iPhone” experience if you will.”

There’s a learning curve

“Unlike previous breakthrough Apple products, the Watch’s software requires a learning curve that may deter some people. There’s a good chance it will not work perfectly for most consumers right out of the box, because it is best after you fiddle with various software settings to personalize use.” – Farhad Manjoo, New York Times.

It’s more fun with friends

digital-touch

“The more your family, friends, and acquaintances adopt the Apple Watch, the better the experience will be… At the moment I have exactly two people on my Digital Touch list, both of whom work for Apple. I would’ve spent a lot more time playing with this feature if my pals were on it.” – Nicole Phelps, Style

It won’t track your sleep

“This seemed odd, because the Watch’s built-in hardware has everything you need to get a surface-level summary of sleep. It could just be that Apple’s expecting third-party apps to own sleep tracking. But more likely, it’s the Watch’s battery life.” – Marissa Stephenson, Men’s Journal

You can’t use it one handed

apple-watch-one-hand

“You simply can’t one-hand the Apple Watch. It’s the simplest thing, but it’s true: because it’s a tiny screen with a tiny control wheel strapped to your wrist, you have to use both hands to use it, and you have to actually look at it to make sure you’re hitting the right parts of the screen. You have to carry your coffee cup in your other hand if you’re not interested in spilling on yourself.” – Nilay Patel, The Verge

It’s great at taking pictures

“One of the Apple Watch’s best tricks is the ability to take pictures. Though, to be clear, Apple Watch does not have a camera. Starting the app opens the camera on your paired phone, and on your Apple Watch you see what the iPhone camera sees. You can tap the watch screen to take a picture or, more usefully, use the countdown option on the app to take a selfie.” – Lance Ulanoff, Mashable

It’s only good for short calls

“Call quality was good, though on balance I found using the iPhone directly better. Also, maybe it’s just me but holding your wrist up to your ear for extended periods got tiring. Calls on the Watch are fun, and best designed for short calls.” – David Phelan, The Independent

Using Apple Pay is dead easy

apple-pay
“It’s incredibly easy to make purchases with Apple Watch. I bought a Shamrock Shake at McDonald’s, where the clerk didn’t bat an eye when I double pressed on the side button, selected the credit card I wanted to use and then waved the watch over the NFC reader,” – Lance Ulanoff, Mashable

Your friends might hate it

“The unexpected side effect to triaging communication around other people is that it made me seem like a Dick Tracy, minus the Tracy. After all, what’s the international gesture for ‘Wrap it up, I have somewhere else to be,’ and ‘This conversation is boring me’? Glancing down at your watch. I found myself in work meetings getting the buzz-buzz-buzz of incoming data, but avoiding looking down to check the updates because I didn’t want to seem distracted or rude.” – Marissa Stephenson, Men’s Journal

It’s going to kill traditional mechanical watches

“Many people, especially in the watch community, have defended their love of traditional mechanical watches by segmenting the Apple Watch in a category of high-end gadgets versus “watches.” While I understand and perhaps even empathize with this sentiment, I disagree. If anything, the Apple Watch is what the wrist watch is meant to be in the 21st century. You might not like that, but it is the truth, when it comes to wearable wrist technology.” – Ariel Adams, aBlogtoWatch

  • Subscribe to the Newsletter

    Our daily roundup of Apple news, reviews and how-tos. Plus the best Apple tweets, fun polls and inspiring Steve Jobs bons mots. Our readers say: "Love what you do" -- Christi Cardenas. "Absolutely love the content!" -- Harshita Arora. "Genuinely one of the highlights of my inbox" -- Lee Barnett.

15 responses to “The 17 best Apple Watch tidbits from early reviews”

  1. Frankie Tommy DeVito says:

    Eh, if I actually get one, it will be at least the 2nd Gen I watched 2 live reviews via Periscope. One reviewer from another site loved it, raved about the battery life – which is a positive. Also showed how easy it was to remove links on the metal bracelet – almost TOO easy. This was the $500+ version, seems like if I banged it by accident walking through a narrow doorway for example, I might dislodge one of the bracelet links. Another reviewer simply said “wait…until the new version OR until the price drops” Uber would not load on his watch what so ever, CNN had issues. If these apps are not 100% finished..then ok. Animated emoji was choppy, the small things mentioned above, the butterfly was not animated. Seems like a disappointment just from what I saw..and from what I read above. (C’mon, no pairing with the iPad? I love Apple, but it seems like things have gone 1/2 a**ed lately.) I was a little psyched when this was teased back in Sept. As time went on, the hype kept growing…oh and again that price – interest faded. After this morning and reading other reviews..Nah, forget it. One last thing, those who want it have to deal with the pre-order system at 3am ET. If not, it’s not like the iPhones. Im sure there will be lines, 1st come 1st serve on launch day – BUT you need a “watch fitting?” if I want the watch, just let me buy it, I dont need a fitting..I’m not buying a fancy suit. My rant / 2 cents. Sorry, carry on

  2. Turtle Heart says:

    Overwhelming BAD reviews across the internet. Your credibility is in the trash here. Other than “Apple can never do anything wrong” clown shows like this one, I have yet to read a review anywhere else that could be called positive. Your take is so phoney, I am going to remove my bookmark for this iIdiot web site. Apple Watch: iGarbage for iFools. Cult of BS really.

  3. dave says:

    There is always a bias on this site, which is to be expected on a site called cultofmac. It happens to be a bias that I share. That being said, I appreciate articles like this very much where there are a lot of pros and cons not just ignoring all the bad (although I have no illusions that there isn’t more negative stuff that could be said if the list was longer)

  4. crateish says:

    Nilay Patel is a fool.

  5. Aannddyy says:

    As with every new Apple release there will these things to anticipate:
    1. There will be some technical issues that need to be fixed. I am guessing three seperate ‘gates’ i.e… bend-gate, antenna-gate But, these will be fixed with software updates.
    2. There will be waves of negative reviews in forums from Apple haters. Some of these will be paid trolls from Apple’s competition.
    3. They will sell out quickly
    4. I’m getting one

  6. Oilsandguy says:

    What is the killer app? Across the board, it seems to be some variation on “not having to go into your pocket for your phone all the time.” …. Washington Post

    ….
    Look, I’m not a paid troll. I chose a battery free (solar face) incredibly durable and cold / heat resistant watch from Casio. I’m one of the few that needs a watch for work.

    Seriously though, it is such a burden to take your phone out of your pocket…. or look at your phone if it is on your desk? Off course you need a phone for any of the features to work. You need a phone to reply to any messages received on your watch. A smartwatch has absolutely zero utility to improve your day. I expect that, like other smart watches have proven, the watches will get little use after about a 3 month heavy trial by owners.

    If anything, it will decrease productivity because you will first be distracted by your watch, then a second step of grabbing your phone to reply.

    It certainly won’t help drivers already distracted by cell phones.

    I’m quite content with just my cell phone, or, uh, ‘pocket watch.’

    So, at best, the phone is a distraction on your wrist. Fact, it can do nothing to improve your life. Free smartphone upgrades on mobile contracts are as much as anyone can possibly need.

    At minimum, your $400 smart watch is not a timeless purchase.

    Once again, I am trying to be rational about the iphone watch. I have a dissenting opinion on smart watches made by any company. Of course I recognize there is a tonne of pent up, frothy demand for a smart watch on the Apple IOS platform.

    Do I expect to be attacked here for my opinion? Let me shake my magic 8 ball…. As I see it, yes.

    • James Alexander says:

      ATTACK. JK. You make good points. I guess everyone needs to find a good reason to get this just like getting anything else. I was going to wait but I figured just getting and enjoy it for a couple of years then get gen 3. From everything I have seen so far I will be able to use it for all the functions that are built in and can only imagine what the DEV’s will do once they get some good time with it.

      • Oilsandguy says:

        Enjoy it! Hell, worse things you can do in your life than buy a smart watch. You will likely find it more distracting than anything. I borrowed a friends watch once for a trial. THe Samsung Gear Fit was fun…. no, I didn’t need to know how many steps I walked…. but the text messaging on a watch was distracting….. and yeah, all the while your phone is in your pocket.

        But again, does the foot or so distance from your wrist to your pocket or desk require a solution? I don’t think so.

      • James Alexander says:

        By far it is easier to look at my wrist than reaching into my pocket all the time. There are many times too I dont have my phone on me so it will be nice to see that info on the watch. I plan on controlling the amount of notifications so I want be distracted. The watch has many features to improve not only my day but help me in other ways my phone cant do as well. Sorry you had a bad experience with another watch.

  7. Eggyhead85 says:

    2 questions.
    1) Does it work on the underside of your wrist?

    2) Can you avoid that distracting buzz buzz of information if you leave your phone in your desk? Also, how much would that affect how the watch works? (As a school teacher, I need a watch with useful capabilities but I don’t need the social distractions. Can you easily silence the thing?)

  8. dasd says:

    Why Choose 1TopSpy Android Tracking Software? Think of 1TopSpy as the master craftsman versus the sweatshop – other products seem similar but they don’t have the quality that comes from experience and attention to detail. Since 2010, when we created the worlds first spy and track phone, we continue to design, develop, test, market and support all our own products. Nothing is outsourced and everything is done under one roof. Unlike others, we also offer a genuine 07 day, no quibble money back guarantee and a Live Support team who are actually part of our company. Choose 1TopSpy Android Tracking App , and not only are you getting unique features like Call Intercept, you get quality created over a decade of technology experience that has been used by over a million people.

Leave a Reply