Top stories

Microsoft’s My Documents Folder Makes Triumphant Return – On iPad

20100209-mydocuments.jpg

Earlier today, I was reading Infoworld’s article, The iPad questions Apple won’t answer. The first question they listed was “Can you save and transfer documents to the iPad?”, and their assumed answer was “No”; they suggested that the only way to do this would be to open a document from an email message.
I read that [...]

Top 5 Things To Check Out at Macworld 2010

Macworld 2010 opens today. It is the 25th annual gathering of Mac users. That’s right, 25 years!
But thanks to the absence of Apple this year, this “Mecca for Mac Heads” may be the last. So check it out while you can.

The show runs for 5 days. The Expo showfloor opens on Thursday at noon.
For the [...]

Opinion: MacBook, or iMac + iPad?

20100208-imacipad.jpg

The announcement of the iPad has done a lot of things: it’s stoked up excitement in the Mac using community, it’s got a bunch of developers feverishly coding exciting new stuff, and it’s got retailers and cell phone companies the world over drooling over the money they can make from it.
And it’s also somewhat upset [...]

In Depth: 30 Days with the Nexus One

It’s been a month since my review of Google’s “SuperPhone”, the Nexus One. Since that time, we’ve surfed, updated facebook, navigated, called, played endless hands of cribbage and even tried to freeze it to death on a trip to Dayton Ohio. Follow me after the jump to find out does the “SuperPhone” stand the [...]

EBook Publisher Calls BS On Apple’s EBook Plans

ipodman415

Entrepreneur Peter Collingridge, founder of Enhanced Editions, an experimental ebook publisher that’s just put out Nick Cave’s The Death of Bunny Munro as an iPhone app, thinks it unlikely Apple is trying to “redefine publishing” as recent reports have suggested.

“Whilst I’d love it if Apple were looking at doing exactly this, I find it unlikely,” he says.

But Collingridge does think there’s huge opportunity in reinventing the ebooks as “digital books,” and that Apple’s tablet presents some interesting UI opportunities.

Founded in 2008 after the launch of the App Store, Enhanced Editions says the iPhone/Touch platform and the iTunes distribution channel is a unique and exciting opportunity. So the company created a networked iPhone app for publishing digital books enhanced with video and audio. “We set ourselves the mission of making the reading software that Apple themselves would make,” the company says.

Following is a QA with founder and book industry vet Peter Collingridge, who has interesting points about Apple, its tablet, the book industry and Apple’s vision of 21st culture.

CoM: Did you see Gizmodo’s story onWednesday about Apple talking to publishers about the upcoming tablet?

Collingridge: I saw the piece, yes, but IMHO it didn’t break any great news. There have been lots of rumours on my radar and yours about Apple talking to (book) publishers for a relatively long time, but very little evidence of a genuine and aggressive entry into books that I think is credible, sadly.

Perhaps they’ve been dipping their toes into the water of print. There have been equally many rumours suggesting that the contractual machinations of publishing deals make the music industry look simple to Apple. But – the examples cited in the Gizmodo piece are fairly dated – a lot has happened since February. Or perhaps nothing!

Personally, I’d be delighted if the rumours were true. Literature and reading is a vital part of our culture both historically and moving forwards, and I think deserves the focus on amazing user experience that Apple brings to any project it launches.

But, if you ask me, Apple has also missed a trick by stating (or misdirecting!) that “people don’t read” and that books won’t be a part of their vision and strategy for culture distribution in the 21st Century. Of course I think this – we’re building a business around doing it ourselves on their app store platform!

CoM: Do you think Enhanced Editions could be a model for the kind of “hybrid” print content Apple is interested in developing?

Collingridge: Our mantra with Enhanced Editions is to create the kind of reading experience that Apple *would* make if they were as interested as us in this cultural industry moving forwards. In practical terms this meant throwing everything we know about “ebooks” away and starting again, focusing on creating a unique and amazing user experience: the digital book rather than the ebook. By combining audiobook, text and video, all synched and integrated in a beautifully designed and networked app, we think we’ve begun that process with The Death of Bunny Munro.

However ours is a bespoke and creative offer; it depends on close and trusted ties with rights holders, and would be hard to replicate on a massive scale. It also depends on the creation of new material and indeed rights. So I think that whilst I’d love it if Apple were looking at doing exactly this, I find it unlikely.

Kindle has shown that there is demand for electronic reading and access to “subscription” content, even at a pretty basic user level, i.e. grey text on a grey background. That’s really encouraging as a starter. But I think and hope that it would take a company with Apple’s vision to see how to take this to the mass market and make something huge out of this opportunity. If Enhanced Editions could inform that vision in any way, I’d be delighted.

CoM: What else could you do with interactive books on a tablet?

Collingridge: Well, I think that’s only limited by imagination. And we’re really working our imaginations – combined with over 10 years commercial experience in the publishing and tech industries – to continue to develop awesome and compelling user experiences that realise these opportunities.

Someone whom I respect very much said to me recently – of the iPhone – that this is a device with “eyes, ears, a mouth, and which knows where it is and which way it is pointing.” When he said that I realised that it was those “characteristics” we were trying to bring into the book through Enhanced Editions – and I would be confident saying that if Apple is doing something around reading, they would feel the same way.

CoM: Is there anything else out there we should be looking at, tablet-media-wise?

Collingridge: As for what else is out there. For me any Tablet is going to be SDK enabled and also announced with enough time for developers to “port” to tablet before launch (Ed: the latest rumors suggest a January announcement and a May or June launch). For reading, my current thinking is that the screen size may actually be too large for comfortable single column reading. So there is a UI opportunity there that we find really exciting.

Looking back on some of the book projects we’ve worked on in the past:

http://www.thegoldennotebook.org/

http://bkkeepr.com/

http://bookseer.com/

I find it really exciting to consider as part of a post-web ecosystem when it comes thinking about a massive adoption of electronic and digital reading.

About the author

Leander Kahney

Leander Kahney is the editor of Cult of Mac, and author of three books about technology culture: Inside Steve’s Brain, the New York Times bestseller about Steve Jobs; Cult of Mac; and Cult of iPod. Leander has written for Wired, MacWeek, Scientific American, and The Guardian in London. Follow Leander on Twitter @lkahney and Facebook.

Email the author | Read more posts by Leander Kahney.

7 comments

    Did he actually read the original Gizmodo piece, since it dealt primarily with newspapers, magazines and textbooks…

    yes Drew he quite possible did.

    And I have to agree and disagree with that article. I don’t think that Apple is actively trying to ‘redefine’ anything in regards to print etc. But I do think that they are making sure that those in said businesses know what is out there technology wise so their limits are widened.

    But we aren’t, I think, going to see any “Published by Apple” titles any time soon. Let others deal with the headaches of rights and such and provide them with the tools and the distribution for a share of the monies is easier to do and easier to get out of if it fails. And you don’t end up looking like another Yahoo or Google, both of whom are and have tried to do a little of everything at once.

    the e-book scene is pretty pathetic when
    the simple addition of audio and video is
    heralded as some great “reinvention”…

    -bowerbird

    1) I look forward to checking it out. Am downloading now.

    2) Holy Download Time! I’m on a WiFi network and it’s creeeeping along. File size of server hit?

    3) I think iPhone App Store is moving in the right direction with O’Reilly books.

    4) If I had the download time of The Death of Bunny Monroe I would not have bought as much volume. Also the cost. O’Reilly books I can get a $30 book for $5. Death of Bunnroe Monroe $25.

    Conclusion. I am still anticipating a good experience whenever this sucker finally gets downloaded. But I do think the hype of Collingridge is a little overplayed as my experience of the salvation his company delivers does not meet a pressing book user case for me, that would lead to volume purchasing. The file size, slow download and expense would not help me with having an on-board archive if reference material that would fill up a book shelf and cost several times less than having the hard-copies. In that, I like the App Store / O’Reilly experience better.

    It’s not a question of either/or here, I just think Collingridge’s wholesale dismissal of current App Store attempts at the e-book is a bit blow-hardish. But he should blow hard. He’s got shiz to sell.

    I love headlines like this, because they’re so patently wrong that they expose journalism from its modern day facsimile.

    Ebook publishers can’t call “BS on Apple’s Ebook Plans” because Apple hasn’t announced any eBook plans. What he’s called BS on is the media’s self-fulfilling (but unsubstantiated) rumour mill about Apple’s eBook plans.

    The two are very different.

    @Darcy

    Yeah. I find the title and the heavy handed statements have created a bit of a backlash in my head. Now instead of just appreciating the Nick cave Multimedia book on it’s own merits, all I can think of is the use cases it does not fulfill, because it established messiah-level expectations for the e-book from Enhanced Edition.

    But the messiah has yet to come. At nearly a gigabyte for this single book, I don’t foresee walking around with an iPhone library well stocked by Enhanced Edition any time soon. If anything it has pointed out that there are some tremendous delivery challenges with what they are trying to do with the e-book. For example: at $24.95 and over 800 MB, I *might* buy a few books that I am really jazzed about. Like let’s say I LOVE Ulysses or Moby Dick, and they do a spectacular media experience around it. I might get one, and port most of them to an external hard-drive (sort of defeating the portability angle). But those are luxury experiences. Like when you by a singed first edition wrapped in calf skin. BUT, most of my book needs (read VOLUME SALES) are in books that I need for reference and learning. I have spend thousands of dollars on just these books. In this way, O’Reilly Books and App Store is kicking ass, selling their own book for $4.99 in a portable form that wont make the second story of my house sag, because of the weight of all the paper, and I can read them on the restaurant crapper.

    So how will Enhanced Edition meet the challenges of the high-end luxury book experience, since that is what they are currently up to? Well…

    1) They won’t stay in the niche and try to diversify to meet other reading use cases (probably a very good idea) AND/OR

    2) They will find ways to make the delivery of their luxury books less of a file size burden. Perhaps by streaming audio/video. Now you have to download all of that, really taking a toll on precious hard drive space. Now I get that that means more server costs for the company, but there may be some serious cost/benefit to do on this.

    3) Stay as-is. Not sure how this will pan out.

    Overall I wish them well. This is a wonderful product. But I mostly say that because I dig the content quite a bit and I was willing to experiment. Will I buy another? Only if they tickle my niche.

    Leander,

    Do you think that Apple will switch to other innovation to accomplish their ebook plan?

Add your comment

Name(Required)

Mail (required, but not published)

Website

Comment

Buy Inside Steve's Brain Buy from Amazon.com Buy from Barnes & Noble