Samsung Argues Leaked Documents In Apple Case Are Public Domain, Admits To No Wrongdoing

Samsung Argues Leaked Documents In Apple Case Are Public Domain, Admits To No Wrongdoing
In the latest filing in the Apple vs Samsung patent case, the Korean-based electronics company argued that the documents they leaked after US District Judge Lucy Koh excluded as trial evidence were public domain, anyway, and that Samsung had done nothing wrong or unethical.

“Contrary to the representations Apple’s counsel made to this Court,” said Samsung lawyer John B. Quinn in a filing this morning, “Samsung did not issue a general press release and more importantly, did not violate any Court Order or any legal or ethical standards.”

“These false representations by Apple’s counsel publicly and unfairly called my personal reputation into question” he added, “and have resulted in media reports likewise falsely impugning me personally.”

Samsung submitted two slides of images of Samsung phone design, and an excerpt from former Apple designer Shin Nishibori for considreation by the jury in the court proceedings. These were excluded by Judge Koh yesterday. Samsung then sent these documents to website AllThingsD, prompting a “livid” response from Judge Koh, though no real sanction.

The filing this morning seems like so much excusing bad behavior, and while it may not be illegal or unethical, Samsung’s behavior certainly smacks of shady tactics, usually a sign of a shaky foundation to begin with. Let’s hope things continue much more peaceably on Friday, when Apple Senior Vice President of worldwide marketing, Phil Schiller, takes the stand to continue his testimony from yesterday.

  • markrlangston

    As the article states, even if releasing the documents isn’t illegal or unethical it doesn’t help that the judge was “livid” about what they did.

    What it does suggest is that Samsung is attempting to win the case in the court of public opinion.

  • zviivz

    Kitchen sink tactics!

About the author

Rob LeFebvreAnchorage, Alaska-based freelance writer and editor Rob LeFebvre has contributed to various tech, gaming and iOS sites, including 148Apps, Creative Screenwriting, Shelf-Awareness, VentureBeat, and Paste Magazine. Feel free to find Rob on Twitter @roblef, and send him a cookie once in a while; he'll really appreciate it.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in News | Tagged: , , , , |