This Is How Much Media You’ll Be Able To Stream Through iCloud Over 3G [Feature]

Video

This Is How Much Media You’ll Be Able To Stream Through iCloud Over 3G [Feature]

An episode of Futurama poking fun at Apple allowed us to test how much video iCloud will let users stream.

To find out how many hours of video iCloud could stream per month on a 2GB data plan, we again decided to compare data taken from a similar video streaming service: Netflix.

Like Spotify, Netflix uses multiple bitrates to encode its shows in various quality streams. What quality a video is streamed in depends a lot on the quality of a user’s internet connection. To test at what bitrate Netflix streams video in over 3G, we loaded up Netflix on our iPad 2 and played the sixth season Futurama episode, “Attack of the Killer App.” After twenty one minutes and forty one seconds, our 2GB data plan was 105MB poorer.

Doing some math, it seems that Netflix streamed video to our iPad at an average rate of 644kbps. According to Netflix, the lowest quality they stream video is at 375kbps and their HD quality encodes start at a whopping 2600kbps.

If iCloud follows a similar compression scheme to Netflix, here’s how many hours of video streaming you can manage in a 2GB plan.

375kbps (Low Quality) — 11.85 hours of streaming per month

644kbps (Medium Quality) — 6.9 hours of streaming per month

2600kbps (High Quality) — 1.7 hours of streaming per month

We don’t know for sure if iCloud will launch with video streaming capabilities, but if it does, these numbers make it clear that if iCloud does support video, it’ll have some serious limitations. Either Apple will allow only videos of a certain size to be streamed, or they’ll lower the bit rate as low as they can. Either way, you won’t be able to watch a lot of video through iCloud: the best you can hope is about six movies a month.

The easiest solution for Apple here is to only allow video to be streamed over WiFi, and I expect this will be the compromise Apple ultimately makes when video comes to iCloud.

Conclusion

This Is How Much Media You’ll Be Able To Stream Through iCloud Over 3G [Feature]

Our final results show that iCloud will supplement but not replace local media storage as long as 2GB data caps are in place.

The bottom line is that as exciting as iCloud is, it’s true potential will be hobbled in the near future by the mandatory 2GB data caps imposed by mobile carriers upon iPhone and iPad customers.

In its current incarnation, iCloud will supplement your iPod, iPhone or iPad’s local media library, allowing you to stream that occasional album or video that you forgot to load up at home. What iCloud won’t do is obviate the need to sync your music and videos to your device manually through iTunes. If data caps ever go the way of the dodo, though, you can bet that’s exactly where Apple intends on bringing iCloud next.

Related

Pages: 1 2

  • lb51

    Would you not expect to see wifi as part of the solution. IMO, I don’t think we would be limited to just phone data usage. If so, then any cloud service is moot for the immediate term. 

  • brownlee

    We mention WiFi augmenting iCloud repeatedly in the piece, so yeah, we totally do see WiFi being a big part of iCloud, but there’s no way to model 3G + WiFi use.

  • Chris Cooper

    It’s all very well for 2GB data caps, but greedy O2 only lets me have 500mb per month on my contract :(

  • NewMex

    Wish Apple would use their cash to build a fast competitor to ISPs with reasonable bandwidth limits for its consumers using Apple products!

  • bluelittlegirl

    As a musician and audiophile, among other things, I listen to music constantly if I am not playing or singing. I even sleep to music. This seems problematic to me.

  • Greg

    good thing I’m still grandfathered in under the unlimited plan

  • Ed_Kel

    I asked a very similar question yesterday via the Washington Post conversation and can’t help but to think that this post was inspired by that! haha! Thanks John for this informative post; it answered every doubt I had about iCloud’s compatibility with our data plans and then some!

  • Pavel Sladkov

    that’s what i call a good fecking idea! 

  • Joel Engel

    The bigger problem is what’s going to happen when the ISPs start metering. 

  • danieljhon

    Apple Letter Disregarded, Lodsys Sues App Developers Anyway
    http://www.gadgets5.com/2011/0

  • bmdonovan

    Currently, mobile broadband providers are setting their caps up as an immovable object. If Cloud entertainment takes off, customers could become an unstoppable force… It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

  • danieljhon

    T-Mobile Sensation 4G Officially Announced
    http://www.gadgets5.com/2011/0

  • Josh

    I’m still on the unlimited plan as well…good thing!!!  My wife isn’t, though.  However, she is ALWAYS on wifi and only has 200 mb per month…only gone over once and they refunded us!  :)

  • Janne

    “The bottom line is that as exciting as iCloud is, it’s true potential will be hobbled in the near future by the mandatory 2GB data caps imposed by mobile carriers upon iPhone and iPad customers.”

    Speak for yourself. I have totally unlimited 3G on my iPad. Not everyone lives in USA you know…

  • cheesy11

    i like what i see as long as its free.

  • brownlee

    Many already are, but the meters are way higher. 150GBs and 250GBs are numbers I’m commonly seeing.

  • brownlee

    My pleasure, Kel!

  • Test

    :)

  • Rui Archer

    It is because of this that I applaud the initiative of one of the Portuguese ISPs, they have set up a subscription music streaming service (beating spotify, zune et al to the PT market), the service is free for those in the highest tiers of ADSL and Fiber, and on some of the mobile plans.

    Plus their offer the bandwidth if you use the service on their mobile network (well it is, for now, only available on their network :D).

    Subscription cost? Free (for some plans)/€3.99(if you have any recurring plan)/€4.99(if you don’t have a plan)/€6.99 (will be the price point for those on other networks) (includes 10 mp3s to keep each month like zune)

    So personally i don’t give a “#$# if spotify is taking too long to expand to other marketMicrosoftrosoft is lagging on broadeningmarketplaceeplace availability or if Google/Amazon/Apple even think that a music locker is an appealing service.

  • mlahero

    Ah just let us have spotify over here, I cant believe it still hasnt been sorted out.

  • Support 18inc

    I have 6GB of data per month for only 30 bucks. Hooray Canada, hooray Fido…I’m not worried.

  • djrobsd

    You guys seem to miss the point that the majority of iPhone users in the US are already grandfathered into an unlimited plan, and even when Verizon first launched the iPhone they were offering unlimited, so most of these limitations you speak of only apply to some of the newer iPhone customers.

    In addition, most people who stream video will probably be near a wifi connection, so really the only people using 3g bandwidth will probably be streaming audio while commuting.

  • Scott MoMo Waite ?

    “The vast majority of iPhone and iPad customers only have 2GB of data per month to play with. How much media can you really stream with a 2GB data cap?”

    LOL – I wish! I get 500mb. I can upgrade to 1gb if I want to, but that’s going to cost even more than the outrageous plan that I’m on at the moment. I pay £42 a month now for an iphone that I bought outright, compared to the £35 that I paid for my BlackBerry on contract.

    One word for this situation? BULLSHIT!

  • wemyss chen

    Dear friends.I invite you to visit my website for news and tips about outdoor digital accessories.Here are two links for best iPhone gloves and latest touch screen gloves
    Just go and have a look.

  • minimalist1969

    As much as I loathe a future with only 3 wireless carriers in the US and think that will be bad for competition, I am actually OK with wireless data caps for the time being.   At least they are being consistent in their application and don;t have any real content of their own to which they can give a free ride.  Everyone competes under the same limitations. 

    Cable internet providers on the other hand have some serious conflicts of interest when their on demand content doesn’t count towards data caps while their competitor’s content does.  Sooner or later their will have to be some sort of government intervention there.   Imagine what would happen to retail competitiveness if Wal-Mart owned the highway system?

  • benjitek

    I don’t think those bandwidth estimates represent anything realistic — there’s no mention of what streaming format is being used for the calculation.  AAC+ streams at CD quality using 64kbs, you’ve got CD quality listed at 320kbs.  I can’t imagine Apple >not< using some sort of wonder-compression method to stream.

    That being said, I imagine those that posted how ‘they’d never come close to a 2gb data cap’ when metered internet was implemented by AT&T are changing their tune about now ;)

  • Anonymous

    Only problem in Canada is that your wired access is the same plan: 6GB for $30.. :P

About the author

John BrownleeJohn Brownlee is a Contributing Editor. He has also written for Wired, Playboy, Boing Boing, Popular Mechanics, VentureBeat, and Gizmodo. He lives in Boston with his wife and two parakeets. You can follow him here on Twitter.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in News, Top stories | Tagged: , , , , , , , , |