(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)

Top stories

Filter posts by: Mac iOS Hardware Software

How To: Make a Profit Upgrading To The iPhone 3G S

Apple's Phil Schiller outlining the great prices for brand new iPhone customers - not existing 3G owners. CC-licensed picture by <a href=

Before you rush out and buy that brand new iPhone 3G S, consider the suggestions here. For some iPhone 3G owners, the 3G S may be unnecessary. For those who simply cannot wait read on, because there are ways to minimize the overall cost of the upgrade. In fact, you may even turn a profit.

The iPhone 3G S will be subsidized by AT&T for qualified customers ($199 for the 16 GB model and $299 for the 32 GB model). Unfortunately, if you currently own an iPhone 3G you are not a qualified customer because you entered into a two-year contract with AT&T last year. Unsubsidized, the iPhone 3G S is priced at an exorbitant $599 and $699 (plus the $18 setup fee).

AT&T is probably not going to alter its stance on the matter because, like it or not, offering subsidized phones only to new customers is standard industry practice. If you are an existing iPhone 3G owner, and do not have money to burn, consider all your options after the jump.

Early Termination

You can cancel your AT&T account and immediately open a new one, qualifying for the subsidized iPhone 3G S prices.

AT&T permits its customers to terminate their contracts early for a fee of $175. This fee is pro-rated: Under your AT&T contract the termination fee is reduced by $5 per month of the contract completed. For example, for those of you who bought your iPhone and renewed your plan in July 2008 your termination is approximately $120 ($175-$55 = $120) since you probably have completed approximately eleven months of your contract.

Aside from the pro-rated fee, AT&T imposes no other penalties for cancellation. Current iPhone 3G owners may cancel their contract and immediately re-enter into a new two-year contract with AT&T. According to a June 10, 2009 phone conversation with an AT&T representative, rumors that AT&T requires a sixty day period to reopen an account after early termination are not true. Moreover, the AT&T representative further explained that you can even keep your old phone number so long as you create your new account within sixty days of canceling your original account. Note — when asked for a source to reference the AT&T representative admitted that this information is not available online.

After a direct inquiry, an official AT&T spokesman stated that early cancellation is inconvenient and may be subject to extra fees and a new number — but confirmed that accounts are not frozen for sixty days. The only other caveat is that AT&T store representatives are not always up to speed with their own policies and procedures and are notoriously incompetent. As of the date of this article, AT&T representatives have confirmed that this is their policy regarding early contractual termination, therefore, be prepared to confirm with your AT&T representative that he/she knows how to ensure that you will keep your old number upon entering into a new contract. If they do not — find a representative who does.

If you choose this option you are looking at adding approximately $120 to AT&T’s subsidized prices as well as the $18 account setup fee that AT&T charges. Your overall cost for the 16GB iPhone 3G S should be approximately $337 and the 32 GB $437 — a saving of $262 in both cases.

Once you get your new account and iPhone 3G S you should consider further subsidizing your purchase by selling your old iPhone 3G.

Subsidize Your 3G S with Your 3G

You can further subsidize your iPhone 3G S by selling your old iPhone 3G on the open market. If you’re lucky, you’ll get up to $400 — making a $60 PROFIT on upgrading to the iPhone 3G S. Even if you do not go through the hassle of termination, you should probably still sell your old iPhone. Each strategy has its benefits. Terminating your contract and subsidizing your iPhone 3G S saves you the most money, but you will be stuck in another two-year contract. Paying full price and subsidizing your iPhone 3G S does not require that you incur any new contractual obligations, but it is more expensive.

At the moment, there are hundreds of people looking to buy and sell iPhones on Craigslist. Even after Apple’s most recent price cut, the unsubsidized iPhone 3G is priced at $499. Depending on size, condition, and location, you can expect to get anywhere between $200 and $400 for your iPhone 3G.

If you plan on subsidizing your iPhone 3G S, consider the following:

Use Your Warranty. First, read this article about getting the most out of your one-year warranty. Although you may not know it, your iPhone 3G may be defective. If you are able to identify a defect, you should take your iPhone 3G into the Apple Store to get it replaced. If you get it replaced, you are going to be selling a shiny new iPhone 3G, not one that has a year’s worth of wear and tear. You will undoubtedly have an easier time finding a buyer and that buyer will probably pay a higher price.

Add AppleCare. Second, if you have AppleCare, great. Be sure to mention it in your advertisement. If you do not have AppleCare, you should consider asking your buyer if they are interested in AppleCare. Remember, you can add AppleCare onto any Apple product at any point during the first year of its life. Since July 11, 2009 has not yet come around you can extend the warranty by another two years through AppleCare. It costs $69 and is fully transferrable to future owners. The only catch is that you will need to notify Apple of the transfer. Notification is very simple and instructions for the transfer can be found in Section 6 of the AppleCare Plan for the iPhone. With AppleCare protection, whoever buys your iPhone 3G can rest assured that it is completely protected.

Find a Buyer. Third, find a buyer. Ideally, a friend is your best candidate. Otherwise, be patient and use Craigslist if possible. If you can conduct the transaction locally you will save money on shipping and avoid other expenses or complications. If you still have them, get all of your original boxing and documentation together. Clean up your iPhone 3G and photograph it for the Craigslist posting. If you just got the iPhone 3G replaced due to a defect; be sure to mention that fact. If you currently have AppleCare, be sure to advertise that. If you do not have AppleCare, be sure to mention the option (reference the fact that Apple permits transfer). Create your Craigslist advertisement and wait. Hopefully you will find a buyer.

Be Smart. Fourth, be honest to the buyer and be safe. You do not want to get into legal trouble for fraudulent misrepresentations regarding the condition of your iPhone 3G. If you are open and candid with potential buyers they will be more likely to feel comfortable and follow through with the transaction. For your own safety, make sure that you choose a public location because you will most likely conduct the transaction face-to-face. Arrange to meet in front of your local Apple Store during daylight hours. This would be ideal because 1) it is a public place; 2) the buyer can verify the existence of the AppleCare Plan; 3) the two of you could probably even use the Apple Store’s computers (the ones on display) to effectuate the transfer of the AppleCare Plan via email ((sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)with subject heading: ATTN: Agreement Administration).

Cash Only. Finally, cash is king. Be careful when accepting checks and money orders. Make it clear to your buyer how you expect to receive payment. If your buyer shows up with a payment method other than what you had agreed upon, beware.

If you take the time to sell your iPhone 3G you can hope to recoup up to $400. If you successfully terminate your account and get a great price by selling a recently replaced iPhone 3G, with a little luck, you may even make some money.

Skip the Hardware — Upgrade Your Software

You will save the most money by simply waiting until your contract has been in effect for eighteen months. Remember, the iPhone 3G S is not a huge upgrade from the iPhone 3G and, therefore, you may simply want to wait until Apple releases the next line of iPhones (probably in about a year).

There are relatively few differences between the iPhone 3G and the iPhone 3G S. Most of the new improvements will be coming from the iPhone 3.0 software, not the iPhone 3G S. In fact, it is somewhat misleading that Apple advertises some of the features that will be available to all iPhones through the 3.0 software as being features of the iPhone 3G S. Many of the improvements listed on Apple’s iPhone 3G S website are actually features of the iPhone 3.0 software, not the iPhone 3G S.

Some of the most talked about features such as landscape keyboard, cut, copy, and paste, MMS (not even available until the end of the summer for AT&T users), voice memos, and many other improvements will be fully available to your regular iPhone 3G or 2G on June 17, 2009. All you need to do is download and install the free 3.0 update through iTunes.

The only new features of the 3G S are: improved battery, improved processor (note that the 3.0 software should improve your iPhone 3G’s performance such that you may not find upgrading to the 3G S necessary), a new 3-megapixel camera (one more megapixel than before), video recording, voice control, and a compass.

For those of you that are strapped for time and cash, the wait-and-see approach is ideal as you may find that the features of the new iPhone 3G S are simply not worth the expense or effort. You may find yourself perfectly happy with the 3.0 software upgrade. The software upgrade is free for all iPhones. There is a nominal fee for iPod Touch users.

If you are looking to buy an iPhone 3G S because you have been experiencing problems with your current model, you may find that a warranty replacement coupled with the new 3.0 software does the trick.

About the author

jzschau

Jonathan Zschau is a Boston-based Massachusetts attorney and occasional Cult of Mac contributor. He has experience in a wide array of practice fields, including business transactions, law & technology, litigation, litigation support, and eDiscovery. He is also the author of Buying and Owning a Mac: Secrets Apple Doesn't Want You to Know.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in Apple, iPhone, iPhone 3G, News, Retail Stores, Top stories |

  • http://www.mr2.org.nz John

    I am actaully really pleased that the 3.0 OS will work on the old 3G iphone. After seeing so many Windows Mobiles simply have to be replaced as the manufacturer wont release upgraded firmware, this action by Apple reminds me more of how Palm used to be, as I went through 3 OS’s on my Treo before the hardware finally died, and each time it actually got better, not slower.
    I hope that some of the improvements are going to be OK on the slower CPU, but to me the killer features are cut/copy/paste, stereo bluetooth and teathering. These are the features I have been using hacked firmware for, so it is nice to have them properly supported now.
    I can’t beleive AT&T managed to cripple the iphone for the whole world becasue they didn’t want their customers to teather.

  • himynameissam

    wait so AT&T will let you end your contract early for $120??

    here in the UK O2 make you pay the number of months you have left times the amount you pay a month, which is like £245 for me, which sucks.

  • accolon

    Quote: “Some of the most talked about features such as landscape keyboard, cut, copy, and paste, MMS (not even available until the end of the summer for AT&T users), voice memos, and many other improvements will be fully available to your regular iPhone 3G or 2G on June 17, 2009.”

    Is there a list what exactly will be part of the 3.0 update especially for the iPhone 2G? I remember reading that MMS will only be available for 3G devices.

  • Sam

    My plan is to ‘lose’ my current insured, carrier unlocked iPhone, collect a brand new iPhone3g which will come unlocked (Vodafone Australia) and send it home to my wife to sell on ebay in the US. I think the market for unlocked brand new iPhone3G will remain strong for some time.

    Australia iPhone 3G-S pricing still hasn’t been announced but it should be similar to AT&Ts (but hopefully with an upgrade plan).

  • http://www.sincerelycookies.com Gregg

    This is great advice. Some appears to be incorrect. Over the weekend I received an email from the manager at the local Apple Store. (I shop there frequently and I am a fanboy…lol) At any rate, I have been in my current contract for 12 months and she indicated that I would be eligible for the upgrade price. Also, with respect to California, there are no early termination clauses for cellular contracts. They are for the most part against the law and basically all that you need to do is say that you are unhappy with the service and they need to let you out of it w/o a termination fee.

  • Mark

    So far, the only 3.0 functionality available to 3G phones but not 2G appears to be Bluetooth stereo. I’ve got a 2G phone and have decided to upgrade, but more for the additional storage and speed than anything else. That said, I am looking to purchase some stereo Bluetooth headphones, too. :-)

  • Peter

    “Since July 11, 2009 has not yet come around you can extend the warranty by another two years through AppleCare.”

    AppleCare on the iPhone goes for two years from the date of purchase of the phone, regardless of the date the AppleCare is tacked on.

  • Bob

    “Since July 11, 2009 has not yet come around you can extend the warranty by another two years through AppleCare.”

    AppleCare for iPhone is a two-year plan, unlike the three-year (from date of computer purchase) plan for Macintosh. Therefore, you can only extend service for “another” ONE year through AppleCare.

    Just thought people should be aware before mistakenly advertising something incorrect on Craigslist.

  • Gav

    If you’re a o2 customer and have insurance, smash your phone, get it replaced. Then sell the brand new phone. You’ll get more for the new one.

  • Jonathan Zschau

    Here are some minor updates that I would like to add to help to clarify a few things. Thank you for all of your comments.

    1) Correction: AppleCare for the iPhone is a two-year plan, not a three-year. Therefore if you purchase AppleCare at the end of your first year you will be extending your warranty coverage by approximately one more year — not two-years. Thanks to Bob for pointing that out.

    2) Correction: there are some circumstances (specific to each customer) that may lead to you being eligible for upgrading at the subsidized price. Check with AT&T to see if your account qualifies. However, in general most 3G owners are not eligible for the subsidized upgrade. Thank you Gregg.

    3) Correction: in addition to the faster processor, the iPhone 3G S does have twice the ram (256 MB) of the older iPhone models. Thank you David.

    4) Correction: it appears that the iPhone 2G will not support MMS or stereo bluetooth. The 2G’s lack of MMS is troubling as MMS has been documented to work on 2G iPhones that have been jailbroken. Seems as if AT&T may have done something to disable this feature for 2G owners. Thanks Accolon.

    5) Clarification: the legality of the ETFs in California is more complicated than one poster has suggested. As I understand it (and I am not a California Attorney) the law is presently in flux and it appears that the recent California cases have dealt with higher, non-pro-rated, ETFs than AT&T currently requires. The cases that have been decided in the last several years have all been very specific in their scope and, therefore, should not be interpreted to symbolize a broad prohibition of ETFs. As it currently stands, the pro-rated ETFs are fully enforceable and you will be required to pay it. Because the FCC is a federal agency its regulatory decisions should be controlling over other states (i.e. California). As of the date of this article, there is nothing that I am aware of (state of federal law) that prohibits ETFs outright. If you would like to read up on the matter here are some links for your enjoyment:

    http://tinyurl.com/nu97sh – CNet article (note the FAQ below).

    http://tinyurl.com/n2ej6z – Engadget article about industry compromise.

    http://tinyurl.com/lf5jmw – FCC hearing information (if you are very ambitious).

  • Richard B

    I have another scenario I’m considering, which may help some others:
    I have the 3G (from last July) and am MacJunkie enough to desire the 3G S. Also, my wife has finally shown interest in an iPhone, but doesn’t care what model. (She’s currently near the end of her current Verizon contract). So, my plan is to open a new AT&T account, (getting the lowest price I can for the 3G S), cancel her Verizon account, switch her # to my old/current 3G and have my current number switched to the new #G S.
    (Unfortunately, SOMEHOW the “water damage” switch was flipped on my 3G, so I’m not even covered anymore for any repairs… which kinda sucks if the phone has a structural problem not caused by me).
    Anyway, make sense? Sound do-able? Thanks!

  • Jonathan Zschau

    Seems there is a little update. AT&T has modified its stance and is offering the early upgrade pricing to more AT&T customers.

    According to a recent press release:
    “We’re now pleased to offer our iPhone 3G customers who are upgrade eligible in July, August or September 2009 our best upgrade pricing, beginning Thursday, June 18.” (http://www.att.com/gen/press-room?pid=1574)

    Depending on your situation, an early upgrade may be easier. However, I would still recommend that you sit down and do the math and make sure that whichever option you choose saves you the most money.

  • http://applefreebiejeebies.co.uk Free iPhone 3GS

    Very complicated, especially when there are places you can get them for free without a contract!!

  • http://espn.com 3gg

    I am eligible for the upgrade at $199 and 299 (16gb, 32gb). How practical would it be to buy a 3GS and sell it in the open market for $800-$1000 (seems to be the ebay prices)? I don’t see how this option is not discussed more. I have a 3G that I am happy with, but wouldn’t mind turning a profit. Let me know your thoughts…

  • CD

    Being about five months into my current contract, I was happy to find out that I somehow qualified for the $299 price for the 32GB. Needless to say, I did with no issues. I don’t know what the specifics are, but perhaps being as new as I was, I was within some window that allowed it.

  • MT

    “If you are able to identify a defect, you should take your iPhone 3G into the Apple Store to get it replaced”, and the author is an attorney. Maybe wrong choice of words.