Instacast Closes One of iPhone’s Most Glaring Gaps [Review]

Instacast Closes One of iPhone’s Most Glaring Gaps [Review]

Way back in the early days of the App Store, an early hot property in the store was Podcaster, a simple utility that allowed users to browse, subscribe to, and download podcasts to the iPhone. It was very useful, both for finding new things to listen to on the go, but also for eliminating one of the key reasons for unnecessary and redundant syncing to a computer.

Naturally, Apple had it removed. Then it came back as RSS Player a few months later. And got stripped out again, in both cases for providing redundant functionality, an absurd claim, as Apple’s built-in iTunes app is only capable of searching for podcasts — subscriptions aren’t allowed.¬†Fortunately, Apple has ¬†finallycome to its senses and now allows podcasting apps to be installed on non-jailbroken phones again, including the original Podcaster. Better still, the choices have multiplied, which brings us to the stellar subject of this review, Instacast.

This $1.99 app (a price I happily paid), approaches phone-based podcast management exactly the way I would like it. Its sole focus is on subscriptions rather than individual files. It uses a simple search mechanism that was able to track down every podcast I wanted to track. It also offers recommendations for popular series. You can also subscribe to any podcast you currently have loaded onto your iPhone. Rather than downloading these podcasts immediately (a potential nightmare), Instacast snags episode descriptions including links to either download or stream any given podcast. Piece of cake.

But the simple power of the app only becomes clearer with longer term use as you build out your library. It implements the increasingly-standard swipe down to refresh gesture first seen in Tweetie. This pulls down descriptions for any newly released episodes within your existing subscriptions and adds them to the existing queue. I have only synced my iPhone once since I downloaded Instacast, and that was to install iOS 4.3.1. I’m actually strongly considering deleting my podcast subscriptions from iTunes.

Now, the app isn’t perfect. Though the UI is fairly intuitive (usually through borrowing conventions of Twitter/Tweetie and Reeder) it has a few oddities, including an easy-to-miss play button, no on-screen volume controls, and no obvious way to delete a downloaded episode (you have to mark it as read). I assume such issues will be resolved in the near future, and the positives definitely outweigh the disadvantages.

In short, Instacast fixes part of a problem of both the iPhone and iPad: much as Apple has defined a new class of mobile computers that doesn’t rely on a desktop or laptop for full functionality, the company has also pushed administration of such devices onto desktop and laptop devices. It’s impossible to boot up an iPad for the first time without syncing it to a computer, and neither machine can install its own software updates without a tether. While this attitude is understandable for firmware and OS updates, it makes no sense for podcasts and other kinds of content. The longer I use Instacast, the more it feels like I’m finally cutting the cable.

Cult of Mac rated:

Rating: ★★★★★★★★☆☆

  • mpfef

    Thanks for posting this, I had been looking for an iOS replacement for my podcasting app I was using on webOS on my old Palm Pre+. This fits the bill just about perfectly.

  • mpfef

    Thanks for posting this, I had been looking for an iOS replacement for my podcasting app I was using on webOS on my old Palm Pre+. This fits the bill just about perfectly.

  • Stangs55

    And how’s it better than Podcaster?

  • Frankie Dewar

    This will likely be my favourite app of the year – like you it has finally allowed me to stop my daily sync to iTunes to download the plethora of podcasts I listen to. I did have Podcaster but it was terrible to use because of the poor interface. There are some quirks to Instacast – I don’t like the audio player interface (you can change volume by double tapping the artwork), and it should be clearer when you are deleting something, but they have been regularly updating so I’m sure they’re working on it.

  • myfreeweb

    You can subscribe with the built-in iTunes app. When you download an episode, you’re automatically subscribed.

  • theguycalledtom

    Podcaster is now very mature and I have stopped podcast subscriptions on iTunes completely. I now only connect my iPhone to my Mac to back up photos and SMS or update the system software. Podcaster is really only limited by the API, I wish apple would let it check for new podcasts in the background, but background downloading is still pretty handy.

    I’ll check out this new app but I think most people will enjoy the maturity of Podcaster.

  • Bill

    Agreed. Podcaster has come a long way. Background checking and download are great. I think the only thing left missing is an easier way to subscribe.

  • matthauger

    Does this sync with your native podcast library (from iTunes)?

About the author

Pete Mortensen

Pete Mortensen is a design strategist for consulting firm Jump Associates and the co-author of Wired to Care: How Companies Prosper When They Create Widespread Empathy, a book and blog that are significantly more interesting than you might initially think. Pete's particular Apple avocations are both around design--interface and industrial. Follow him on Twitter!

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in Reviews | Tagged: , , |