The 128GB Retina iPad Is The Desktop To The iPad Mini’s Laptop [Opinion]

The 128GB Retina iPad Is The Desktop To The iPad Mini’s Laptop [Opinion]

So similar, and yet so different…

With Tuesday’s’s announcement of a 128GB iPad 4, Apple is clearly signaling that the iPad is not only suitable for serious work, but that it can be the primary machine for many users. Most commenters have fixated on fitting extra movies and other consumables into the extra 64GB of space, but they’re forgetting about work.

In fact, I’d say that the iPad With Retina Display, as Apple now insists on calling it, is the new desktop machine, and the iPad mini is the new laptop. Why? Let me explain:

Desktop Vs. Laptop
104971-mac-desktop-vs-laptop-2

The choice is no longer clear cut.

If you could live with less power, but valued portability and always having your machine with you, then you chose the laptop.

Historically (at least before Apple choked the Mac Pro and kept improving its MacBooks), the tradeoff between desktop and laptop computers was power vs. convenience. If you wanted a big screen, lots of storage or the most powerful processor then you bought a desktop. If you could live with less power, but valued portability and always having your machine with you, then you chose the laptop.

I have been using the regular iPad as my main machine for months now. In fact, if I quit using BitTorrent as a source for TV shows, I could ditch my MacBook altogether. For writing, planning, editing photos and movies the Retina iPad is more than capable. I use it for watching TV shows, movies and reading. In fact, I not only use it for work, I actually prefer it, finding that I get more done, and faster.

I was happy. Then Apple made the iPad mini.

Enter The Mini
Can you work on an iPad mini? You might be surprised.

Can you work on an iPad mini? You might be surprised.

I struggled for long weeks not to to buy one. I told myself the non-retina screen was crappy. I told myself that it would be too small. And yet every time I picked one up it felt great in my hand. Or rather, it felt almost nonexistent in my hand, so impossibly thin and light is its shell.

So I bought one. I figured I’d get the cheapest model, the 16GB with wifi. For comparison, I own a 64GB iPhone 5, and a 64GB cellular iPad 3. Buying the non-cellular, smallest-capacity mini showed just how much of a toy I expected it to be (in the end, the Las Vegas Apple Store [Hey Drew!] was out of white 16GB minis, so I bought the 32GB, and it turns out I’m glad I did).

Nobody questions it when you have an iMac and an MacBook, so why should iPads be any different?

But a strange thing happened. Like almost every journalist who has written about it, I found I used my regular iPad less and less. The mini is easier to carry with you. It fits into a pocket. It doesn’t annoy you by trying to fall out of your hand as you read.

And amazingly enough, it’s good for work. Yesterday, I used it for my whole work day, from writing to editing to editing some images.

But this isn’t yet another article about ditching the iPad for the mini. It’s about using both, and maybe ditching your Macs. Here are some Tweets in response to my question asking what the Retina iPad does better than the mini:

landscape typing & easy reading: the features I value most for business use. For personal use text clarity is key difference.

much better graphics if you are a gamer (nova 3, gta..)

Text readability, obviously. Landscape typing (but not portrait). Gaming. That’s about it.

giving arm-muscles.

comic reading, undoubtedly

I’d definitely rather edit on a full-size iPad, if just for accuracy!

Besides resolution, it’s performance (A6X vs. A5, 1GB RAM vs. 512MB). And that’s about it!

Power. Screen size. Screen resolution. More comfortable typing. All things that the desktop historically did better than the laptop.

Apps, Not Movies

The extra storage space in the 128GB iPad could hold more movies, but what it’s really for is apps. Phil Schiller, from the 128GB iPad press release:

With twice the storage capacity […] enterprises, educators and artists have even more reasons to use iPad for all their business and personal needs.

I can swap movies on and off my iPad, thanks to iTunes Match and re-downloadable content. But I can’t delete the projects I have in iMovie, nor the journals I keep in iPhoto. And I’m sure there are specialist users with huge amounts of data in their specialized apps, and musicians with giant GarageBand libraries. These are the “enterprises, educators and artists” Schiller is talking about. Here’s how I use them:

The Case For Two iPads

ipad-mini-and-ipad-retina-tablet-daylight-2-small

So the 128 GB iPad is the new “desktop,” with power, capacity and that gorgeous, amazing screen. And the mini is the laptop, the compromise, the little device that’s so convenient that you can forgive the fact that it contains the guts of an iPad 2.

Retina iPad

  • Watching movies
  • Editing photos and movies, and storing photos
  • Working

iPad mini

  • Reading
  • Email
  • Checking news and browsing
  • Comics
  • Traveling
  • Everything else

There’s a lot of crossover between the two. I can work on the mini, but the bigger screen is more comfortable, and if I’m typing without a Bluetooth keyboard, the full-sized iPad’s soft keyboard is close to full-speed for me (editing is another matter…). And the 1GB RAM enjoyed by the bigger iPad means much less time waiting for apps (and Safari tabs) to reload – this is maybe the biggest difference between the two when working.

Maybe the biggest difference between the machines is the Retina iPad’s 1GB RAM.

The Retina iPad is clearly better for reading books and comics, but the mini is, like a laptop “good enough.” It’s also so light that it disappears as an object. It’s also easier to pull from a pocket to check maps, or to use one-handed whilst standing (the mini is vastly superior as a kitchen computer for this reason alone).

Then we get onto the dirty little subject of battery life. The mini does last a little longer than the Retina iPad, but that’s not the whole story. The iPad mini ships with an iPhone adapter. Apple surely did this to save money, and to make the shipping containers smaller, but it also demonstrates that the mini can be charged almost as quickly as an iPhone. You can use it for days and – when the battery warning finally shows – you can plug it in and it’s full again before you know it.

The Retina iPad, on the other hand, takes all night to charge. Try using it while you charge it and it’ll take even longer, the needle creeping so slowly towards the “full” mark that you’ll wonder if it’s even moving at all. I have taken to keeping my Retina iPad plugged in when watching TV shows just because it takes so long to recharge the battery afterwards.

This is the biggest marker between the “laptop” and “desktop” functions of the two machines. One is heavy and likes to be near a power outlet. The other is so light and so power-frugal that you can treat it like an iPhone, or (almost) like an e-reader.

Conclusion

So while it initially sounds dumb, I really can make use of two iPads.

I really can make use of two iPads.

Maybe this will change when Apple makes a Retina iPad mini that’s as thin as the current one, and that doesn’t need a shrunken car battery to run it, just as a modern-day MacBook Pro is almost a match for the current Mac Pro. But right now, I’m happy with using both a desktop and a laptop iPad. And why not? Nobody ever questioned me when I used an iMac and a MacBook, so why should it be any different with tablets?

  • darkhuntress

    Totally agree. I have a use for all of my Apple products. My iMac, MacAir, iphones and ipads so I can certainly find a use for the 128. Must buy…must buy…must buy…..

  • djrobsd

    Totally disagree. The iPad is hardly a desktop replacement. I’d like to see how long it takes you to edit a video on an iPad versus on a Macbook Pro. I’d like to see you try to make a full on PowerPoint, board room ready, presentation on an iPad (oops, sorry what’s that they don’t make PowerPoint for the ipad yet?!). I’d like to see you edit a CAD drawing… Oh wait, they don’t make CAD software on an ipad, and even if they did, it would be far too small to actually work with. Not buying your logic at all. Laptops and desktops are content creation devices. iPads are merely content consumers… Which is why I still bring my MBP with me on any lengthy trip.. Only use the ipad on weekend trips.

  • Jonathan Ober

    djrobsd, I would totally agree and disagree with you. It’s obvious that the author is writing about his day to day, sure an iPad isn’t going to work for everyone for what they do. I know I can’t design a website on one, but I can code using Diet CODA and several other coding apps, wordpress for editing my sites that are on the platform, writing proposals, creating KEYNOTE…who needs powerpoint when Keynote can do it and better. I manage Spreadsheets Documents and more from Apple Apps, third party apps or from Google Docs. It’s simple for some to put down the desktop or laptop and go all iPad, but it’s not going to work for everyone. As far as the device being Consume only…I really have to disagree with that.

  • dab76

    I have to agree with the author. Today, is the first day that I have used my Mac in over 3 months. I love it…but, I just don’t need it anymore. I’m a writer and a full time student and I can do everything I need to do right on my iPad. I also, edit video on my iPad and it works just fine. I know that some people can’t do everything on an iPad. But, the day is coming when desk/laptops will be gone and I welcome it!

  • katakwi

    Good article. I like my ipad but for long term use I still prefer imac/macbook air due to ergonomic reasons. If you use a keyboard for many years you will get used to feel and spread of the keyboard. If apple had keyboard which “fully” worked with ipadX i would consider buying this model for sure.

  • MatthewHowell

    This article was a very interesting read, I hadn’t thought of the concept of “Desktop” and “Laptop” iPads before. There are two reasons, for me, that I still use a MacBook Pro as my main machine: Watching Non-iTunes Store videos on my Apple TV and Virtualization.

    I have many Non-iTunes Store videos that I watch on my Apple TV and, without an iTunes Library to import them into, I’m not sure how I could watch them on my Apple TV. I also work in I.T. (self-employed) – since the vast majority of my clients use Windows machines, I need a way to walk them though issues if I’m helping them over the phone (options like GoToAssist or LogMeIn are not always feasible for various reasons).

  • MatthewHowell

    Good article. I like my ipad but for long term use I still prefer imac/macbook air due to ergonomic reasons. If you use a keyboard for many years you will get used to feel and spread of the keyboard. If apple had keyboard which “fully” worked with ipadX i would consider buying this model for sure.

    I found one, on Amazon.com, that has a row of “iOS Specific” buttons.

    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B004HCO4GI/ref=oh_details_o06_s00_i00

  • Lee Hammond

    My iPad mini has fit into my mobile life [and coat pocket] even more quickly than I expected. I have a 1st gen iPad sulking in a corner somewhere but I am still using my iMac and MacBook Air.

About the author

Charlie Sorrel Charlie Sorrel is the Reviews Editor here on Cult of Mac. Follow Charlie  on Twitter at @mistercharlie.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in Featured stories, News, Top stories | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , |