Doxie One Scanner: Just Go Buy It Already [Review]

I thought I had the whole “paperless” thing under control until Doxie sent over the new, budget-priced Doxie One for me to review. Trust me: If you snap photos of your receipts with your iPhone in an attempt to banish dead trees from your life, you should probably switch to a portable scanner.

It really is that much better.

The Doxie One is essentially a cut-down version of the Doxie Go. Here’s a list of the things it doesn’t do/have that the Doxie Go does:

  • Built-in rechargeable battery (you can put in 4 rechargeable AAs, though)
  • USB slot for scanning to thumb drives
  • Built-in memory
  • Optional Wi-Fi add-on dongle
  • 600dpi “archival” resolution (it scans at 300dpi)

What you do get is a scanner than can swallow an A4 page in 8 seconds and store it on an SD card. From there, you can either put that SD card into your iPad using a camera connection kit, put the SD card into your Mac, or hook the scanner up to the Mac via USB and import into the excellent Doxie app for further processing

The Good

As I hinted, scanning with the Doxie is absurdly easy. You can hook it up to AC power and just leave it on your desk. When you need to scan, long-press the power switch, poke your paper or business card into its maw and the motors will pull it through. Done. It’s super-fast, and all you need to do is recycle the paper.

Getting the documents out is also easy. They’re stored as JPG images so the iPad can import them to its camera roll, and the Doxie app will take these files (you can import them direct from the scanner if you just plug it into the Mac – sadly the USB bus won’t power the scanner, though) and perform various tasks on them.

The Doxie is very well connected, letting you share to Dropbox (and pretty much every other cloud app, including Google Docs and even Flickr), as well as local export to Evernote, or just a folder on your hard drive.

The Doxie app also uses Abbyy OCR to turn printed text into searchable text (although it won’t work on handwritten notes). This is my favorite option, as it lets you either save the resulting PDF with one of three views: text only, an image with text hidden under the scanned image but selectable, or with the image visible but with text placed over the top. All have their various (dis)advantages.

You could also just save the raw JPGs and have an app like PDFPen take care of the OCR part. I let Doxie do its thing and then use Hazel to performa automatic filing and renaming based on the text in the document. It’s like frikkin’ magic.

The Bad

Not much. The only downside comes when you compare the $150 Doxie One to the $200 Doxie Go: Is the $50 saving worth the loss of 600DPI scans, a rechargeable battery, scanning to a thumb drive (good for older Mac which lack an SD slot) or optional Wi-Fi capability? You’ll have to decide. If I was buying one, I’d opt for the Doxie Go, mostly because I don’t like dealing with AA batteries.

But if all you’re doing is scanning papers in your home, then why not take that $50 and spend it on a nice dinner instead? Just remember to scan the receipt afterwards.

The Verdict

This scanner is so worth $150 it’s not funny. It’s so fast and easy to use, and the software so well-suited to batching work, that I routinely scan every piece of paper that passes through my hands. And why not, when I can have a searchable, archived PDF of every receipt in my Dropbox? Better yet, that same receipt weighs in at just 15kb, an absurdly small file.

My advice? Buy it. Or buy its bigger brother if you need the battery and better resolution for photos. Only if you regularly process a ton of paper should you bother looking at the Fujitsu Scansnap or the auto-feeding scanners from Canon. Like I said – save you money for dinner.

Rating: ★★★★★

Doxie

  • sydster

    Thanks for a the review…what I’m more curious about is your scanning workflow and auto-naming via Hazel…would you mind sharing?

  • thepominlaw

    These look great so good I bought one for myself as a christmas present, anyhow I spoke to Doxie and they fully support any Eye-fi X2 card so I now know what else is on my list to santa!

  • michaelra

    I did a review on Doxie One before on my blog

    Just want to share that you HAVE TO use their rechargeable batteries (the eneloop’s – the ones in the photo). You can put in the regular Alkaline batteries but it won’t scan. So it may be something to think about. They aren’t expensive though but that means you can’t just buy the Alkaline batteries in a shop when you are on the go and need to scan

  • doxiescanner

    Thanks for a the review…what I’m more curious about is your scanning workflow and auto-naming via Hazel…would you mind sharing?

    You may want to check out the workflow that Shawn Blanc put together using his Doxie and Hazel: http://shawnblanc.net/2012/09/the-paperless-puzzel/

    If you have any questions about Doxie or about going paperless please let us know at (sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address). We’re always happy to help! :)

    Amanda
    Doxie Customer Care

  • JoriKostiainen

    Here’s an app-based alternative for a portable scanner.

    DocScanner: Scan Multipage Documents to Beautiful PDFs

    Available on the App Store

    https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/docscanner-scan-multipage/id312391317?mt=8

  • Guest

    ScanSnap S1100 blows the Doxie away. I bought both and returned the Doxie. Here are some of my major complaints.

    – Wireless scans are JPEG natively. If you want PDFs, you will have to convert them with their software. This extra step is terrible, and you’ll lose quality.

    – You can’t use Doxie with USB. Has to scan wireless.
    http://help.getdoxie.com/doxiego/faq/scanner/chargeandscan

    – You’ll be hesitant to scan a document on the go and throw away the original because you can’t confirm the scanned result unless you have your phone or computer with you. At this point, the wireless function does not seem so wireless when you’re checking another device to confirm the scan. Using Eye-Fi to confirm documents wirelessly is a cumbersome process.

    – You can’t open the Doxie like the ScanSnap to clean it with compressed air or clean it thoroughly. You have to use a swab back and forth. I wouldn’t want to risk rubbing any sort of debris in there that accumulates from traveling. The ScanSnap can open up.

    – The Doxie is bigger than the ScanSnap.

    – You have to place receipts on the left edge of the scanner. The ScanSnap will scan a receipt regardless of where you insert it.

About the author

Charlie Sorrel Charlie Sorrel is the Reviews Editor here on Cult of Mac. Follow Charlie  on Twitter at @mistercharlie.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in News | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , |