RIM’s BlackBerry Loses The Mobile Security Crown To Apple’s iPhone and iPad

RIM’s BlackBerry Loses The Mobile Security Crown To Apple’s iPhone and iPad

IT administrators have finally warmed up to the iPhone and now rank it as more secure than the BlackBerry.

The perception of the BlackBerry as the most secure and manageable mobile platform seems to be faltering. According to a new report, senior IT administrators now consider Apple’s iOS to be the most secure and manageable platform – despite the fact that RIM offers ten times the number of security and device management policies that Apple provides in iOS.

Update:  Decisive Analytics, not Trend Micro, was responsible for the survey and report. Trend Micro was not involved with the survey or authoring the report as our initial coverage may have indicated. Any comments or conclusions about mobile platform security and management capabilities reflect the IT leaders surveyed by Decisive Analytics and do not represent Trend Micro’s position.

The report by research firm Decisive Analytics was based on a survey more than 400 senior IT professionals in the U.S., U.K. and Germany about security related to bring your own device (BYOD) programs that allow and/or encourage employees to use personal devices like iPhones, iPads, BlackBerries, and Android devices for business tasks.

The survey results (PDF Link) included a range of surprising results, but one of the most significant is that the BlackBerry is losing its reputation as the most secure mobile device money can buy. When asked to rank the range of mobile devices currently on the market or in use by employees in terms of security and manageability, the IT executives surveyed ranked iOS the highest with RIM’s BlackBerry OS coming in second followed by Android in third place and Nokia’s Symbian OS in fourth.

Such an opinion among IT executives could be particularly damning for RIM. During the company’s ongoing problems with market focus and struggles to reinvent itself, RIM has held onto the badge of outclassing the competition when it comes to security. The company has repeatedly highlighted the security and device management feature set of BlackBerry handsets paired with RIM’s BlackBerry Enterprise Server (BES) and its use in various government agencies and markets known for security like the financial industry as reasons that the company isn’t in dire straights.

This shift shows that IT professionals are becoming more comfortable with iPhones and iPads. Part of the change in mindset may also be due to the fact that many mobile security experts now view mobile application management (MAM) and encrypted on-device containers for confidential data as better mobile security tools than management of device features.

Ironically, despite ranking iOS as the most secure platform, the IT exectutives surved by Decisive Analytics noted that they organizations are more likely to restrict employees from using iOS devices than BlackBerry handsets or Android devices.

There are multiple operating environments associated with consumer mobile devices, and many companies restrict those that will be permitted for use on the company network. Most common among permitted devices was Blackberry (71.2%) followed by Android (70.6%), Windows (52.5%), iOS (50.7%), and Symbian (25.5%).

Asked to rank the abovementioned operating systems for their security and manageability, iOS fared best, followed by Blackberry in second place, with Android close behind ranked third. Symbian came in fourth, with Windows in last place.

The survey also found that nearly half (45%) of companies that offer BYOD programs  have experienced at least one mobile data security breach.

Related
  • Nick2103

    One of those blogs you need to create an ID to leave a comment. Ryan understood… you did not make this up but its almost a SIN to even compare iOS security with Blackberry. Read the Trend Micro report, the authors obviously do no substantiate or provide sources their claim.

    Lets see – BB
    1) Blackberry cannot be Jail-broken(never has been)
    2) BES has 550+ IT Polices – “there is a policy for that” ;) get it
    3) In addition to IT policies BES has over 30 Application Control Policies – Best Application Control by far
    4) BES provides end-to-end AES 256 Encryption for data in motion
    5) Provides AES 256 on-board content encryption and ability to encrypt media card

    Lets see – iOS
    1) Gets Jailbroken mostly on the same day by a 16 yr old (exaggerated but al most true)
    2) About 50+ IT Policies
    3) No Application Control policies ( Al though App Management/sand-boxing at an OS level is much secure to Android)
    4) At rest encryption when device password locked is AES 256 – kind of even here
    5) Does not provide any additional “data in motion” security generally using 128 bit encryption

    But comon when you can have Siri provide you al most all the info you ask even when locked its actually funny and scary at the same time.

    I really wish when people write a paper like that they provide detailed reasoning when making such claims.Next thing you know someone will write a paper saying BB apps are slicker looking than iOS

    In sequence:
    1) Blackberry
    distant 2) iOS (with MDM) tie with Samsung SAFE (MDM)
    3) Generic Android – 1.6 – 4.1 used with MDM/ Touchdown/3LM integration

  • murnende

    Take another look at your source material. Either the information presented in the .pdf has changed, or you misquoted it.

    “Blackberry fared best, followed by iOS in second place, with Android
    close behind. Windows came in fourth followed by Symbian in last place”

About the author

Ryan FaasRyan Faas is a technology journalist and consultant living in upstate New York who has written extensively about Apple, business and enterprise IT, and the mobile industry. In addition to writing for Cult of Mac, he is a contributor to Computerworld, InformIT, and Peachpit Press. In a previous existence he was a healthcare IT director as well as a systems and network administrator. Follow Ryan on Twitter and Google +

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in News | Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |