One Year Later, Disgruntled iPhone App Developer Still Disgruntled

Ex-iPhone app developer Mike Ash, who has abandoned the platform because of Apple's "nonsense."

Ex-iPhone app developer Mike Ash, who has abandoned the platform because of Apple's "nonsense."

One year after disgruntled iPhone App developer Mike Ash wrote about his frustrations trying to get his software approved by Apple, he says nothing has changed. The App approval process is so bad, in fact, he’s giving up altogether.

“I have abandoned the platform,” he writes. “Apple’s nonsense is just too much for me. There’s no joy in iPhone development, and an enormous amount of frustration.”

Last year, Ash wrote a high-profile blog post about his experience working with Apple. Detailing all the hoops he had to jump through, and several rejections of his software, Ash’s post drew a lot of attention from blogs and a lots of comments from developers who’d had similar experiences.

Apple’s approval process has long been the subject of criticism and frustration. The process is secretive and opaque, and developers often complain apps are often rejected or held up without good reason. Google’s Voice App, for example, is still undergoing approval — a roundabout way of rejecting an app from a big and important partner without actually rejecting it.

Apple’s head of marketing, Phil Schiller, has tried to smooth ruffled feathers by reaching out to unhappy developers. The biggest problem with Apple’s process is the sheer volume of apps submitted for approval. Apple’s 40 full-time testers must scrutinize about 8,500 apps a week, according to information from Apple in response to an FCC inquiry. Each app is reviewed by two testers, so that’s about 80 apps a day, per reviewer — every day.

In his latest post, Ash says the consumer’s experience of the App Store has marginally improved, but behind the scenes, nothing has changed for developers.

DON'T MISS
Apple Responds to Ninjawords Censorship Tempest

“Apple VP Phil Schiller has been making noises about trying to improve things, but so far this is just talk,” Ash writes. “Apple’s improvements, virtually insignificant already, have mostly gone to improving the store, not the development process.”

It’s so bad, he’s given up completely. Ash says he’ll write software for the Mac instead, which requires no approval process.

About the author

Leander Kahney

is the editor and publisher of Cult of Mac, and author of three books about technology culture: Inside Steve’s Brain, the New York Times bestseller about Steve Jobs; Cult of Mac; and Cult of iPod. Leander has written for Wired, MacWeek, Scientific American, and The Guardian in London. Follow Leander on Twitter @lkahney and Facebook.

(sorry, you need Javascript to see this e-mail address)| Read more posts by .

Posted in Apple, iPhone, News |

  • Matthew

    Why doesn’t he try the Cydia Store? Of course its for jailbroken users only, but no approval needed and it’s just better altogether!

  • http://www.metrokids.ca Conrad

    What did this guy try to develop?

  • http://youtube.com/solidkwon kwonstein

    Macs don’t have an approval process? Interesting. Well, in any case, Apple does need to really improve the iphone development process. 40 testers sounds like a pretty big number to me but 8,500 apps a week, whew, they’re gonna need more testers and easier criteria testing if they want to speed up the process.

  • http://www.kazzmedia.com Kevin Cassidy

    /cry

    if apple won’t approve your app then sell it elsewhere like everyone else who

  • Dr.Evil

    Yes. Time to move on to that lucrative Zune marketplace.

  • PMoe

    How complicated is this guy trying to make his fart app?

  • salsa

    Odd, it seems to work for thousands of other developers.

    Maybe re-title this posting as “Malcontent Complains: ‘I Can’t Be Satisfied’”?

  • Dale Smith

    What a complete crock of poo. Your link to this guys first submission indicates that he submitted this App with serious bugs twice and had to wait four weeks before a final approval after the problems were resolved. Big friggin deal. Your blog doesn’t disclose what the latest “Bad Apple” screw up caused this whiny jerk to reject the App store.

  • http://www.teabuzzed.com Fred

    Yep and Obj-C sucks.

    No offense SJ. Love Snow Leopard BTW. but yeah x-code and obj-c are just awful.

    Good garbage collection would be a nice start.. It’s the modern thing to do..

    Good article.. I’m never touching xcode again. Only apps I’ll deploy on the iPhone will be through Safari from now on.

  • Yep

    another whining developer, isn’t there any real news?

  • Yep

    Wow, another whining developer, isn’t there any real news?

  • chris

    Sounds to me like the app approval process is working as intended. Keeping the crap garbage that developers like this are trying to get published, off the app store.

    I for one, welcome our new AppStore overlords :P

  • a FAILpalm

    Great, another drama queen.

  • Fuzzypig

    40 testers? They’re Making enough spondoolics to at least double that measly staff count surely?!

  • Charli

    so apparently this guy thought he could just snap his fingers and boom, he’s got his app making him some dough.

    sorry love, but no.

    his ‘hassles’ weren’t really all that major. complex yes but much in this biz is. and he should know that being a computer developer as well.

    so cry me a river.

    apparently his stellar product wasn’t so stellar the first couple of times out and he got caught on it. boo hoo.

    but in the end, he got the program approved, which is better than some of the squeaky wheels out there.

    but hey, if he’s done with the iphone, big whoop. I don’t see that his precious program was really all that wonderful anyway. i mean come on, app that lets you wake up your computer but only if it is connected via ethernet. how is that so important. oh well I see he also has a rather lame looking Golf game also. added in May of this year (after his ‘wretched’ experience with NetAwake).

  • Paul

    His iPhone app was buggy that’s and that is why it was rejected so he then takes his frustration out on Apple. What a looser. Can’t wait to see what your Mac app will be because I’ll be sure not to buy it. Please go develop for the Zune you jerk! You’re perfect for the Microsoft market.

  • SunhilTD

    Just curious: can something actually be opaque but not secretive? Secretive but transparent?

  • David Westebbe

    “The biggest problem with Apple’s process is the sheer volume of apps submitted for approval.”

    You lie. The biggest problem is that Apple has silly policies, inconsistently applied.

  • Commenter

    Reading the comments here, I’m getting the impression that a lot of people simply will not tolerate any criticism of Apple…

  • Jim

    @Commenter: You’ve just figured that out now???